A five-song EP bristling with energy and pummeling guitars,
Metal Circus is the first indication of
Hüsker Dü's greatness. With these five songs, the band shows more invention, skill, and melody than it did over the course of a full album with
Everything Falls Apart, and both
Bob Mould and
Grant Hart emerge as significant songwriters. While they both stay within hardcore conventions on
Metal Circus, their songs illustrate that they would break free of its constrictions on their subsequent, masterful double album,
Zen Arcade.
–
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi